By Canadian Press

B.C. Court of Appeal upholds murder conviction for Vancouver Island prison escapee

Apr 11, 2025 | 2:22 PM

VANCOUVER — The British Columbia Court of Appeal has upheld the first-degree murder conviction of James Busch, who escaped from a Vancouver Island prison in 2019 with another inmate, then killed a man who lived near the institution.

Busch and fellow inmate Zachary Armitage escaped from William Head Institution, a minimum security prison, on July 7, 2019, and 60-year-old Martin Payne was murdered in his home the next day.

The Appeal Court ruling says Payne was found dead on his bathroom floor days later “in a pool of blood, with duct tape on his leg and arm.”

It says Armitage eventually pleaded guilty to the killing, but Busch continued on with a trial that focused on whether he was involved in the murder to some degree, “if at all.”

A jury found him guilty of first-degree murder in 2022, but he appealed the conviction claiming the lower court judge gave improper instructions about his “potential liability for aiding a planned and deliberate first-degree murder.”

2025 FEDERAL ELECTION

Advance voting opens this Easter weekend; Elections Canada reminds voters to check their cards

11h ago

2025 FEDERAL ELECTION

Candidates clash on carbon tax, trade and tariffs at Battlefords-Lloydminster-Meadow Lake forum

13h ago

Catching Attention

Locals among prospects in final NHL Central Scouting ranking ahead of Draft

Apr 16, 2025

The three-judge panel dismissed the appeal Friday, finding the judge gave “well-structured and organized” jury instructions that boiled down complex legal concepts to be “easily understood,” rejecting Busch’s appeal that focused on “one narrow area” of jury instructions.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 11, 2025.

The Canadian Press